Cathode 'Defects' Improve Battery Performance
A counterintuitive finding revealed by high-precision powder diffraction analyses suggests a new strategy for building better batteries
February 5, 2020
Corresponding author Peter Khalifah (left) with his students/co-authors Gerard Mattei (center) and Zhuo Li (right) at one of Brookhaven's chemistry labs.
UPTON, NY—Engineers strive to design smartphones with longer-lasting batteries, electric vehicles that can drive for hundreds of miles on a single charge, and a reliable power grid that can store renewable energy for future use. Each of these technologies is within reach—that is, if scientists can build better cathode materials.
To date, the typical strategy for enhancing cathode materials has been to alter their chemical composition. But now, chemists at the U.S. Department of Energy’s (DOE) Brookhaven National Laboratory have made a new finding about battery performance that points to a different strategy for optimizing cathode materials. Their research, published in Chemistry of Materials and featured in ACS Editors’ Choice, focuses on controlling the amount of structural defects in the cathode material.
“Instead of changing the chemical composition of the cathode, we can alter the arrangement of its atoms,” said corresponding author Peter Khalifah, a chemist at Brookhaven Lab and Stony Brook University.
Today, most cathode materials are comprised of alternating layers of lithium ions and transition metals, such as nickel. Within that layered structure, a small number of defects can usually be found. That means atoms from a transition metal can be found where a lithium ion is supposed to be and vice versa.
“You can think of a defect as a ‘mistake’ in the perfection of the material’s structure,” Khalifah said. “It is known that a lot of defects will lead to poor battery performance, but what we’ve come to learn is that a small number of defects should actually improve key properties.”
Khalifah says there are two properties that a good cathode material will have: ionic conductivity (the lithium ions can move well) and electronic conductivity (the electrons can move well).
Zhuo Li (left, co-author) and Liang Yin (center, first author) with Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) instrument scientist Kate Page (right) at ORNL's Spallation Neutron Source. Photo courtesy Peter Khalifah.
“The presence of a defect is like poking a hole between the lithium ion and transition metal layers in the cathode,” he said. “Instead of being confined to two dimensions, the lithium ions and electrons can move in three dimensions across the layers.”
To make this conclusion, the scientists needed to conduct high-precision experiments that measured the concentration of defects in a cathode material with far greater accuracy than has ever been done before.
“The concentration of defects in a cathode material can vary between two and five percent,” Khalifah said. “Before, defects could only be measured with a sensitivity of about one percent. In this study, we measured defect concentration with exquisite accuracy—a sensitivity of a tenth of a percent.”
To achieve this precision, the scientists conducted powder diffraction analyses using data from two DOE Office of Science User Facilities, the Advanced Photon Source (APS) at DOE’s Argonne National Laboratory and the Spallation Neutron Source (SNS) at DOE’s Oak Ridge National Laboratory.
Powder diffraction is a powerful research technique that reveals the location of individual atoms within a material by directing beams of x-rays, neutrons, or electrons at the material and studying how the beams diffract. In this study, the scientists conducted x-ray measurements at APS and neutron measurements at SNS.
“This work has developed a new way of visualizing structural defects and their relationship to diffraction and scattering strength,” said Saul Lapidus, a physicist in the X-ray Science Division at APS. “I expect in the future for this technique to be used commonly in the battery community to understand defects and structural characterizations of cathode materials.”
Khalifah added, “the ability to measure the concentration of weakly scattering elements with the sensitivity of a tenth of a percent will also be useful for many other areas of research, such as measuring oxygen vacancies in superconducting materials or catalysts.”
With such accurate measurements of defect concentrations, the scientists could then study the relationship between defects and cathode material chemistry.
Ultimately, they developed a “recipe” for achieving any defect concentration, which, in the future, could guide scientists to synthesize cathodes from more affordable and environmentally friendly materials and then tune their defect concentrations for optimal battery performance.
This study was supported by DOE’s Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, Vehicle Technologies Office. Operations at APS and SNS are supported by DOE’s Office of Science.
Brookhaven National Laboratory is supported by the U.S. Department of Energy’s Office of Science. The Office of Science is the single largest supporter of basic research in the physical sciences in the United States and is working to address some of the most pressing challenges of our time. For more information, visit https://energy.gov/science.
2020-16984 | INT/EXT | Newsroom