CERN Experiment Sees Hints of a Rare Kaon Decay

NA62 experiment in CERN's North Area enlarge

NA62 experiment in CERN's North Area. (Image: NA62/CERN)

This story about an observation of a possible rare kaon decay event at CERN originally appeared on the CERN website on March 27, 2018. The story mentions earlier searches for these rare decays at the U.S. Department of Energy’s Brookhaven National Laboratory. Two experiments at Brookhaven's Alternating Gradient Synchrotron (AGS) observed seven such events from 1995 to 2002. For more information about the Brookhaven Lab work, see the related links that appear after the CERN story. Note that Brookhaven Lab will host a speaker from Canada's TRIUMF laboratory to discuss the new CERN results on May 24.

What if the odds of an event occurring were about one in ten billion? This is the case for the decay of a positively charged particle known as a kaon into another positively charged particle called a pion and a neutrino–antineutrino pair. Yet, such a rare event, which has never been observed with certainty, is something that particle physicists really want to get their hands on. The reason? The Standard Model predicts such one-in-ten-billion odds with an uncertainty of less than ten percent. A deviation from this prediction, revealed by a precise measurement of the decay, could therefore be a clear indicator of physics beyond the Standard Model.

In a seminar taking place today at CERN, the NA62 collaboration reports a candidate event of this ultra-rare kaon decay found using a new “in-flight decay” approach. While this single event cannot be used to probe beyond-Standard-Model physics, it demonstrates that the approach works well and can be applied to catch more events in the next run of data-taking, which kicks off in mid-April. The result was also presented earlier this month at the Rencontres de Moriond conference(link is external) in La Thuile, Italy.

To look for kaon decays, the NA62 team first makes beams rich in kaons by firing high-energy protons from the Super Proton Synchrotron (SPS) accelerator into a beryllium target. The collision creates a beam of nearly one billion particles per second, only about 6% of which are kaons. Next, the team sends the beam through a Cherenkov detector, which positively identifies the kaons from the Cherenkov radiation that they produce. A silicon-pixel detector then determines the momentum of the kaons with a time resolution of 100 picoseconds (1 picosecond is one trillionth of a second). A device called a straw tracker, placed inside a vacuum tank, in turn measures the momentum of the charged daughter particles into which the kaons decay, and another Cherenkov detector called RICH determines the particles’ type. Other devices known as calorimeters reject unwanted background events with photons and muons.

In their analysis of data taken over the course of 2016, the NA62 team identified a candidate event of the decay of a positively charged kaon into a positively charged pion and a neutrino–antineutrino pair that escapes undetected. The result allowed the researchers to put an upper limit on the relative frequency, or “branching fraction”, of the decay of 14 in 10 billion. The result is compatible with the Standard-Model prediction, which is 8.4 in 100 billion (with an uncertainty of 1), but more data is needed to probe beyond-Standard-Model theories, which predict deviations from the Standard-Model value.

NA62's candidate event of a rare kaon decay enlarge

NA62's candidate event of a rare kaon decay. Octagons show hits in the RICH detector. Circles show predicted "Cherenkov rings" for positively charged pion (π+), positively charged muon (μ+) and antielectron (e+) decay particles. (Image: NA62/CERN)

This is not the first time that hints of this decay have been observed. Several candidate events have been previously reported by the E949 experiment and its predecessor E787 at Brookhaven National Laboratory in Long Island, New York. These candidate events have been used to infer a branching fraction of 17.3 in 100 billion (with an uncertainty of about 11), which is consistent, within large errors, with the Standard-Model prediction.

But there is a difference between the Brookhaven experiments and NA62: whereas the former observed the kaon decays with the particles at rest in a target, NA62 observes them while the particles are in flight within the vacuum tank. This new in-flight approach has advantages because it provides much more room for detection and background-event immunity.

The NA62 team expects to identify more events of the rare kaon decay in the ongoing analysis of a twenty-fold-larger dataset taken in 2017, and it will begin taking data again in mid-April for a record number of 218 days. If all goes to plan, the collaboration should be able to measure the branching fraction of the decay with a small enough uncertainty to make a precise test of the Standard Model.

Tags: physics

2018-12849  |  INT/EXT  |  Newsroom